FIGO Committee for the Ethical Aspects of Human Reproduction and Women’s
Health.
Committee Statement.
Introduction
The FIGO Committee for the ethical Aspects of human
Reproduction and Women’s Health considers the ethical aspects of issues that
impact the discipline of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Women’s Health. The following documents represent the result of
that carefully researched and considered discussion. This material is not
intended to reflect an official position of FIGO, but to provide material for
consideration and debate about these ethical aspects of our discipline for
member organisations and their constituent membership.
Ethical
Guidelines in the Prevention of Iatrogenic Multiple Pregnancy
Introduction
- In recent years there has been
a dramatic increase in multiple pregnancies throughout the world. For
example, some countries have reported a doubling of twin pregnancies and
the quadrupling of triplets over the last twenty years. The relative
increase in higher order pregnancy has been even greater.
- Undoubtedly, the main factor
has been the use of ovulation inducing drugs and of multiple embryo transfer
in the treatment of infertility. The increase in twin pregnancies may also
be attributed in part to a trend towards increased maternal age at
conception.
- The need for infertility
treatment has also been rising sharply due to factors which include the
trend towards pregnancy at later ages, and the impact of sexually
transmitted diseases.
- Multiple pregnancy has very
serious implications for the mother and her offspring, for the family and
the community, and for health service resources. To give examples: the
maternal mortality may be increased 3 fold for twin pregnancy and even
more for triplet pregnancies; with triplets as compared with singletons
the incidence of birth weight < 1,5 kg has been reported to be
increased 75 fold, the perinatal mortality raised 9 fold, and the
incidence of cerebral palsy 16 fold. The parenting required for triplets
has been estimated at 197 hours per week. The resulting physical and
emotional stress commonly leads to psychological problems within the
family. In addition the financial cost to the health service and
community, as well as to the family may be 100 to 200 times greater than
with a singelton pregnancy.
Recommendations
- Every effort should be made to
prevent infertility. Further research is required. Women require education
on the consequences of delaying pregnancy until late in their reproductive
lives. They should also be made aware of the risk of infertility
associated with sexually transmitted disease, such as chlamydial
infections, and other risk factors.
- Obstetrician-gynecologists have
an important responsibility to make both the public as well as their
patients aware of the many hazards associated with multiple pregnancy,
especially with triplets and higher order pregnancies. In addition, they
must make them aware that the high risk nature of multiple pregnancies
requires an expertise that may be beyond that available in some rural or
smaller town areas.
- Research and education is
urgently required to improve the technologies of assisted reproduction.
Reduction in the incidence of iatrogenic multiple pregnancy and the
problem of increasing monozygosity are important areas of study.
- The misuse of drugs for the
induction of ovulation is responsible for at great deal of iatrogenic multiple
pregnancies. Therefore, those using these drugs should be familiar with
the indications for their use, their adverse side effects, ant the methods
of monitoring and preventing iatrogenic multiple pregnancy.
- Obstetrician-gynecologists
using assisted reproductive technologies, whether by the induction of
ovulation or the transfer of pre-embryos (in all stages of development
including blastocysts), should aim to achieve singleton pregnancies. Under
optimal conditions, not more than two pre-embryos should be transferred
although circumstances of age and other clinical considerations may
warrant three or, in exceptional circumstances, four. International and
national professional bodies have a responsibility to issue
recommen-dations for good practice with a view to reducing the incidence
of iatrogenic multiple preg-nancy. There is a need for accreditation or
certification of centres in order to ensure a uniformly high standard.
- The risks for both mother and
her resulting children with triplet and higher order pregnancies are
sufficiently great to justify consideration by the couple and their
medical advisers of the use of fetal reduction.
- In order to monitor and
regulate professional practice, audit of the use of these technologies
should include not only the fertility success rate but also statistics on
the incidence of mul-tiple pregnancy, the use of fetal reduction, the
maternal and perinatal mortality and morbidity, the incidence of preterm
delivery and low birth weight, and the occurrence of long term
disabilities among the offspring. International, national and local centre
statistics should be available to couples wishing to use these services.
- Couples seeking treatment for
infertility must be fully informed of the risks of multiple pregnancy both
to the woman and to their potential progeny. These risks are so numerous,
complex, and potentially far reaching that they should be fully explained and also given in writing.
Counselling should also be abailable from an experienced paediatric member
of the perinatal team. Proper informed consent should be obtained for the
use of ovulation inducing drugs and other assisted reproductive
technologies.
London, May 2000, Copyright IJGO